Google
 
Web DVJ
      

ANIME-MOVIES
NEWS
REVIEWS
ADVANCED REVIEWS
THEATRICAL REVIEWS
COOL VISION VIDEO

MANGA-BOOKS
MANGA REVIEWS
BOOK REVIEWS
MAGAZINE REVIEWS

MUSIC
J-POP REVIEWS
SOUNDTRACKS
MUSIC VIDEOS

VIDEO GAMES
REVIEWS
NEWS
CONCEPT IDEAS

INTERVIEWS
ANIME FRONTIERS
SPECIAL INTERVIEWS

EXTRAS
COSPLAY
PARODIES
CONVENTION REPORTS
THE VOICE BOX
10 THINGS WE WANT

DVJ CREDITS
ADVERTISE
QUOTES
CONTACT
CONTESTS
TOUR DVD VISION JAPAN
LINKS

SUPPORT DVJ

 

 

THE FOLLOWING WEBSITE IS SUPPORTED BY: 

Click here to order from The Right Stuf

BATTLE OF THE PLANETS

Company: Rhino Video

Running Time: 120 minutes (5 Episodes)

Region: 1

Rating:PG (Violence)

Back to the review page

SUMMARY

In the distant future, an evil group of aliens called Spectra have decided to take over the solar system. In order to combat this evil, 7 Zark 7 has brought together a team of 5 individuals, each with cerebonic implants that gives them cool powers. They call themselves G-Force, and they are ready to protect the universe!

OR

In the year 2001, an evil terrorist group called Galactor have decided to take over the Earth. In order to combat this evil, Dr Nambu has brought together a team of 5 individuals, trained as ninjas, and equipped with devices that gives them cool powers. They call themselves the Science Ninja Team Gatachaman, and they are ready to protect the world.

OR

In the year 2001, an evil terrorist group called Galactor have decided to take over the Earth. In order to combat this evil, Dr. Brighthead has brought together a team of 5 individuals, trained as ninjas, and equipped with devices that gives them cool powers. They call themselves G-Force and they are ready to protect the world.

DVD VISION TEST

VIDEO: Well, these are direct transfers of the source material, so no clean up has been done. While the transfer is free of pixels and rainbows, there is some slight color bleeding in a couple of the Battle of the Planets episodes. Also, the source prints are full of scratches and nicks, and the DVD shows every single one.  You can also see some sort of signal errors with the Gatchaman episodes, which can be very annoying.

AUDIO: With so many different tracks, we will break them down by versions.

Battle of the Planets: There is a re-mixed 5.1 and the original Mono track. Frankly, the 5.1 is very muddled and cluttered. The elements are so bad that is sounds like someone packed towels around the speakers. The mono track is clearer and easier on the ears. This is an example of why sometimes, you should not remix the audio for the audiophiles.

Gatchaman: Since it is the original Japanese audio track in 2.0 sound, it does not have a lot of funky surround sound elements. However, it is still better than the Japanese VHS release, and is the preferred way to watch this series.

G-Force: The 2.0 English track it the worse of the bunch. It is very low pitched with little or no directionality. It sounds like it is coming out of my old B&W TV set. To add insult to injury, the 1 channel Spanish track is better than the 2.0 English. Mind you the 1 channel Portuguese is only a little better than the 2.0 English.

EDITS: Are you kidding? Everyone knows of the severe editing done by Sandy Frank Productions. 7 Zark 7 and his crew in Center Neptune were never in the original version, and any scenes of death were edited out.

With Gatachaman, these are uncut and untouched. Now, you can see the way this series was intended.

The G-Force episodes only have changes to the open and close animation. The episodes are intact.

An interesting side note, most of the original background music from Gatchaman survived the transition, and is used in most of the episodes.

EXTRAS: Well, since the DVD is Battle of the Planets, the addition of Gatachaman and G-Force episodes are the extras. No other extras on this volume.

WIDESCREEN REVIEW

STORY:Okay, there are three different versions of Gatchaman, but the story is the same. So we will break them down by how they are written.

Battle of the Planets: While the dialogue is horrible, you have to give them some credit for having to in-cooperate the new character of 7 Zark 7 into the existing story line. Other than that, it is overly preachy and very un-groovy. Some of the major points are glossed over, or totally changed.  


Gatchaman: The scripts are well written. Each of the characters are well defined and you get a sense of who they are, by what they say.. Junpei gets most of the clever lines, while Joe gets all the bad-ass lines.

G-Force: Well, they didn't tell us who wrote the episodes, so we haven't a clue as who it is that gave us some of the worse dialogue in the history of animation. At least BOTP dialogue had some subtle innuendo. While the others showed the diversity of the characters, G-Force writers make everyone the same. (I want to go. No me. No me.)

ACTING: Excellent on the Japanese front. The characters are full of passion, emotion. You feel the power of Ken's leadership as voiced by Katsuji Mori. Jun (Kazuko Sugiyama) is absolutely sexy, with her classic sounding vocals. My favorite will always be Noboru Tanaka as Governor X. He has the right mix of menace and intelligence. Plus, he does it all with very little voice modulation.

The English actors on both versions are horrible, despite having veteran voice talent (Kasey Casem on Battle of the Planets and Jimmy Flinders on G-Force). Because of a combination of poor writing, and bad directing, these people all sound like they just did it to get paid. There is no emotion or passion in either version. The Spanish and Portuguese are fine, but since I don't speak either, it is a little difficult to determine if it is good or not.

FAN SERVICE: Well, it's the 70's man, so Jun (or Princess, or Aggie, or....) has her panties flashed at least once an episode due to her short skirt. Other than that, this disc has no real fan service.

EPISODE GUIDE:

VOL 1: The first two episodes introduces the members of G-Force/Science Ninja Team.  We meet what will become the archetypes for many Japanese "Sentai" shows.  You have Ken, the strong leader.  Joe, the dark one, who kicks a lot of ass.  The beautiful (some would say token female) Jun, who is actually stronger than she looks.  Gentle giant Ryu, and Junpei, the youngest and least mature of the team.

While a few deaths, and the character of Dr Nambu have been "omitted", for the most part, These episodes are unchanged.

What is up with Terets-Boy Keyop messed up speech? I swear he says "My bare a$$" and "Fu** Off".

 

VOL 2: It's giant mummies and bugs attacking the Earth, or planet Zarkania.  However these episodes are less about monsters, and more about the loss of family.  In both episodes, secondary characters loose their fathers due to the evil of Glactor/Spectra.  Angry at the pain these nefarious villains have caused, Ken looses his cool and makes some very questionable moves.

Most of the changes lie in the writing.  With the exception of Dr Harland in episode 4, no one dies.  Sure some fighter jets get blown up, as do Spectra henchmen, but they are only robots.  Poor Dr. Harland's death is also glossed over, and Mark reflecting over his grave is a lot shorter than Ken's in Gatchaman.  There are many more changes to the characters between BTOP and Gatchaman, but I think you get the picture.

There are Three edits that really stand out. Ken and Chief Nakahara bowing after they met, and Ken punching Nakahara's teenage daughter in the gut when she attacks him.  In further violence against women, Ken also bitch slaps her for not firing the missiles.

 

VOL 3: Like Cobra from "G.I. Joe", Glactor/Spectra has come up with some disparate plans.  First they try an invasion force with UFO's in sunken ships.  Then they send little robots to rob a bank.  Now, all they have to do is use metallic bugs to steal candy and world domination is complete.

Some major changes were done in these two episodes.  One such change involves the Red Impulse fighter squadron. In episode 5, "The Ghost Fleet From Hell" (Gatchaman title) we are introduced to this mysterious fighter group.  In later episodes, the Red Impulse will play a major part in the war against Galactor, and a startling secret involving Ken will be revealed.  

In "Ghost Ship of Planet Mir", we are told that Brock, the deposed leader of Mir has aligned with Spectra.  Yet in the next episode "Big Robot Gold Grab", he isn't Brock anymore, just a nameless henchman.  You would figure that if they were going to "amp" up a minor Gatchaman character, they would keep him the same in both episodes.

 

VOL 4: News flash: Glactor/Spectra actually wins a couple of battles.  The fight between Gatchaman/G-Force goes up a notch, with the evil organization causing some major setbacks for our heroes.  With the evil Bi-Plane pilot Katesnberg destroying planes and a giant sea anemone attacking subs, it seems that the Science Ninja Team may not win this chapter of the war.

Perhaps the most bizarre character we have met to date is Katesnberg/Captain Doom.  First, it takes a real man to wear a skull mask and purple leggings and still appear menacing.  What makes this character so bizarre is that in "Gatchaman", Katsenberg is really a disguised Berg Katsu.  On the "Battle of the Planets" side, the writer made him into a new character, who was working against Spectra.  Confusing?  Sure.

 

VOL 5: More terror and evil is being wrought on the good citizens of Earth.  This time, it's Armageddon!  Well not exactly.  The "meteors" are not from a rouge comet, but from a robotic bug that chews up moon rocks and shoots them out it's butt.  No, I am not making this up.  For some reason, the bugs are on Calisto, one of the moons of Jupiter, in Battle of the Planets.  The fact that you can see the "blue Earth" in the background must have escaped the notice of the writers.

More bugs cause havoc with robotic ants attacking everything they can find.  While fighting Galactor in her mini dress does not bother Jun, bugs do.  She squeals and hates toes ikky things.

 

VOL 6: Okay, this volume really shows the differences between Battle of the Planets and Gatchaman.  That difference can be found with the Red Impulse.

In Gatchaman, the Red Impulse was a top secret army created by Dr. Nabu to perform offensive attack.  The leader of the Red Impulse is none other than....(gasp) Ken's Father!  It seems that dad "disappeared" years ago but is presumed dead.   Where the differences come into play is the fact that the writers for BOTP had turned the Red Impulse from a secret army into fighters from planet Mir (or Glactic Federation Fighters, or Fighters from planet Riga) . So, they turned Ken's father into Colonel Chronos from Planet Riga.  Apparently (due to the witty repartee), the two have met before.  If you have watched volume 1-5 of Battle of the Planets, you know that this is this is the first time they have actually met.  Since BOTP episodes were shown out of sequence, this is not a big shock.  So now, the entire sub-plot involving Ken and his father is totally FUBAR!

Remember when I said that if Glactor used metallic bugs to steal candy, their plans for world domination would be complete.  Well, they do.  While the actual episode was cool, it reminded me of the "Inspector Gadget" episode where MAD replaces all the milk with MAD Milk.  Since this series reached 102 total episodes in Japan, God knows what else they are going to steal.

 

CONCLUSION:

This is a classic, make no bones about it. The name G-Force evokes the same response in the US as the name Gatchaman does in Japan. Full of fast action, cool machines, and inventive plots, very few series can come close to the energy this anime has.

While many bemoan the heavy editing that Sandy Frank had to do (standards and practices were very strict back in the 70's), his company should be given credit to bring something that few people would be willing to take a risk on, a Japanese cartoon. Despite the edits, for us older viewers, still remember yelling out "Transmute!" when we were playing with the neighbor kids. Like Star Blazers, this series will never be forgotten.

Battle of the Planets, unfortunately, may forever be stigmatized by the fact that it was so badly edited, and that the dialogue was just as bad as Speed Racer. Especially the character of Keyop, who sounds like he suffers from Terets (Chikerup whoop whoop whoop my bare hands!) The inclusion of the queer sounding 7 Zark 7 makes most purist cringe. However lets be honest. At the time Battle of the Planets came out, no one noticed how bad it was

It also appears that the writers were a bunch of dirty old men as well as "hackers" (hack writers). First, what is up with the phone-sex voice for the computer Susan?  "It's--gasp--only has a---gasp---million miles--gasp range!".  Apparently, her talk gets 7 Zark 7 pretty hot.  He also finds "Princess" very pleasing to look at, but he does not know way.  Maybe it's because when he says this, there is a shot of her panties while riding her hover cycle? 

Another sex reference is the "did she come on!" remark made by Tiny in vol 4.  Basically, some unknown island ho came on to the tubby teddy bear, and they did the nasty!  So, let me understand this.  Death is not cool, but Tiny talking about his sex life and 7 Zark 7 getting a rise in his rectalfier is?  What exactly was the purpose of "Standards and Practices"?

Years later, things got better with G-Force. Despite the bad acting and writing, the episodes themselves remained unedited. Unfortunately, the constant and overly receptive 80's back beat drives me nuts, and it makes it hard to watch. That and the poor audio quality.
Despite any problems I may have with the writing or acting,  Rhino should be congratulated for their work on this series. Truly a "Perfect Collection", this series has Gatchaman, Battle of the Planets, and G-Force all on one disc. Now the purists can see this wonderful series the way it was intended, and the nostalgic who loved Battle of the Planets can revisit their old childhood friend.

Despite it's age, Battle of the Planets will always remain a part of anime history. So, get your transmuter ready, and pick up this series of DVD's.

Return to Top

Back to the Review Page

ŠAll information protected by DVD Vision Japan copyright unless otherwise noted.