ANIME-MOVIES
NEWS
REVIEWS
ADVANCED REVIEWS
THEATRICAL REVIEWS
COOL VISION VIDEO

MANGA-BOOKS
MANGA REVIEWS
BOOK REVIEWS
MAGAZINE REVIEWS

MUSIC
J-POP REVIEWS
SOUNDTRACKS
MUSIC VIDEOS

VIDEO GAMES
REVIEWS
NEWS
CONCEPT IDEAS

INTERVIEWS
ANIME FRONTIERS
SPECIAL INTERVIEWS

EXTRAS
COSPLAY
PARODIES
CONVENTION REPORTS
THE VOICE BOX
10 THINGS WE WANT

DVJ CREDITS
ADVERTISE
QUOTES
CONTACT
CONTESTS
TOUR DVD VISION JAPAN
LINKS

SUPPORT DVJ

THE FOLLOWING WEBSITE IS SUPPORTED BY: 

Record of Lodoss War

The Grey Witch (Vol. 3)

Review by: Jim Lancaster

Author:  Ryo Mizuno

Artist:  Yoshihiko Ochi

Company:  CPM Manga

Length:  222 pgs.

Category:  Fantasy

Rated:  PG 13 (Violence)

Back to the Manga-Books page

PREFACE

Young Parn is a hero in search of a cause.  

Having inherited the armor and sword of his father, Parn must constantly fight to live up to his father’s tarnished legacy.  When Parn realizes that the forces of darkness are descending on the island of Lodoss, he sets off to defend his homeland.  The combined power of the Emperor of Marmo and the Grey Witch seems to be unstoppable. 

However, all may not be lost.  Parn does pick up a few friends along the way to aid him in his quest.  They are all brave fighters, but will their small group be enough to prevent the complete destruction of Lodoss?

The final confrontation is here!  Kings and their armies clash on the battlefield.  Parn must find a way to deal with the Grey Witch’s awesome power once and for all.  The fate of Lodoss hangs in the balance, but can Parn make a difference and save the day?

MANGA VISION TEST

ARTWORK:  Yoshihiko Ochi’s artwork is perfect for this story.  His character designs are all unique and distinct, and do a great job of showing off each character’s individuality.  The artwork and backgrounds are very detailed, which helps create the illusion of this fantasy world.  Most importantly of all, the action is easy to follow and all of the swordplay is very intense.

SOUND EFFECTS:  The original Japanese sound effects have been removed and replaced with English translations.  Care has been taken not to disrupt the flow of the artwork, so I have no problem with this approach.

EDITS:  Other than the sound effects, there seem to be no obvious edits or changes made to Record of Lodoss War. The art is flipped to read from left to right.

EXTRAS:  The only extras in volume three are two brief creator biographies.  These also appeared in the first two volumes.

BOOK REPORT  

STORY:  Ryo Mizuno has clearly set out to create a very vivid, believable and detailed fantasy world in Record of Lodoss War.  In the tradition of fantasy sagas like the Lord of the Rings novels, Mizuno has obviously thought carefully about the details of his world.  As bits and pieces of back-story are revealed, the history, politics, and legends of Lodoss slowly become clear.  The level of narrative detail found here makes "Lodos Wars" the kind of story that will definitely benefit from repeated readings.

TRANSLATION:  The translation seems very accurate, and very carefully done.  Each character’s unique voice comes through clearly.

CHARACTERS: The most important characters here are clearly Parn and his band of heroes.  Parn is a young, enthusiastic fighter for justice and all that is right in the world.  He lived through a difficult childhood, and takes his responsibilities as a hero very seriously.  He can be a bit hotheaded at times, but always strives to do what is right.

Etoh is a childhood friend of Parn, and a priest of Pharis.  He is eager to help Parn, and also to curb some of his friend’s more excessive acts of heroism.

Deedlit, the sole female member of the group, is a warrior from the High Elf clan.  She is at least 160 years old, but doesn’t look a day over 18.  It is apparently fairly rare for her kind to be wandering the world, but Deedlit has decided that she can no longer sit by and watch as her world goes to war.

Ghim is a dwarf from the Northern Tribe, and is traveling the world in an attempt to rectify what he views as a past mistake.  Like Parn, he has a strong desire to see justice done and is eager to help in the quest to save Lodoss.  In the second volume, Ghim discovers an unsettling connection between the Grey Witch and the missing girl he has set out to find.

Slayn is a sorceror who doesn’t quite know what to do with himself, so he joins up with Parn.  He soon finds that his former school has been destroyed by the very forces that threaten Lodoss, and becomes even more involved in the struggle to save the island.

The last member of the group is Woodchuck, a thief who spent twenty years in prison for a minor crime, and decides to turn his thievery skills to good use by helping in the defense of Lodoss.  At times, Wood’s motives seem a bit suspect.  Can Parn truly trust him to overcome his selfish nature?

FAN SERVICE:  There is not really any fan service to speak of in this series.  Deedlit’s skirt is fairly short, but there are no panties to be seen here.  Deedlit would probably take a sword to you if you even tried to peek.

FOOTNOTES:

As the third, and final, volume of The Grey Witch series begins, it is clear that war is inevitable on Lodoss.  The kings of Lodoss begin to form alliances in the desperate hope that they can hold off the advance of Emperor Beld’s troops from Marmo.  Karla, the Grey Witch, continues to interfere, but it becomes very evident that she is on no one’s side but her own.  Only Parn and his friends may be able to restore the balance destroyed by Karla’s meddling.

In this volume, explanations come fast and furious.  We learn the motives behind many of the characters actions, and that knowledge makes the disastrous consequences all the more tragic.  King Beld, acting on a promise made in his youth, truly believes that Lodoss can only be at peace under the guidance of one strong ruler-himself.  Karla believes that continual war is essential to the survival of society.  King Fahn of Valis, however, believes that Beld and Marmo cannot be allowed to rule.  All of these people want what they believe is best for Lodoss, but their differences cannot be resolved without bloodshed.  The fact that all of these power-players are former comrades, much like Parn and his group, makes their current circumstances even more unfortunate.

When Parn, Ghim and the others learn the truth behind Karla’s identity, the challenge of defeating her becomes even more difficult.  Our heroes are faced with difficult choices that truly test their friendship.  Ghim makes a shocking discovery, and Woodchuck has to decide, once and for all, where his loyalties lie.  As all these conflicts come to a head, it seems entirely possible that not everyone will survive the final battles.

Things happen almost TOO quickly in the final volume of The Grey Witch.  There are parts of this story where the exposition is piled on just a bit too thick.  You may also get the feeling that Ryo Mizuno was in a rush to finish his story, not only because of the heaped on explanations, but also because of some strange omissions.  One such odd bit is when King Fahn warns Parn about the terrible danger he will face on a mission through the horrific Cave of Evil .  He is told to look out for dragons, ogres and all manner of terrifying beasts.  Yet, for some reason, Parn and friends are suddenly at their destination, none the worse for wear and the dreaded Cave is never seen or mentioned again.  In fact, they make the trip twice, and we never see them pass through the Cave of Evil .

This one complaint aside, Record of Lodoss War:  The Grey Witch volume three provides a satisfying conclusion to the trilogy.  There is plenty of action, a few very surprising revelations, and the main storyline is wrapped up.  There are a few loose ends left to be dealt with in the sequels, but readers get a complete story with this first series.  If you are a fan of the sword and sorcery genre, or if you just enjoy a rousing adventure, you really shouldn’t miss Record of Lodoss War: The Grey Witch.

Return to Top

Back to the Manga-Books Page

©All information protected by DVD Vision Japan copyright unless otherwise noted.