Google
 
Web DVJ
      

ANIME-MOVIES
NEWS
REVIEWS
ADVANCED REVIEWS
THEATRICAL REVIEWS
COOL VISION VIDEO

MANGA-BOOKS
MANGA REVIEWS
BOOK REVIEWS
MAGAZINE REVIEWS

MUSIC
J-POP REVIEWS
SOUNDTRACKS
MUSIC VIDEOS

VIDEO GAMES
REVIEWS
NEWS
CONCEPT IDEAS

INTERVIEWS
ANIME FRONTIERS
SPECIAL INTERVIEWS

EXTRAS
COSPLAY
PARODIES
CONVENTION REPORTS
THE VOICE BOX
10 THINGS WE WANT

DVJ CREDITS
ADVERTISE
QUOTES
CONTACT
CONTESTS
TOUR DVD VISION JAPAN
LINKS

SUPPORT DVJ

 

 

THE FOLLOWING WEBSITE IS SUPPORTED BY: 

Maison Ikkoku (Vol. 1)

Review by: Jim Lancaster

Author:  Rumiko Takahashi

Artist:  Rumiko Takahashi

Company:  Viz

Length:  214 pgs.

Category:  Romantic comedy

Rated:  PG 13 (brief nudity, adult situations)

Back to the Manga-Books page

PREFACE

For high-strung student Yusaku Godai, home does not provide a tranquil or acceptable study environment.  Godai lives at Maison Ikkoku, and the bizarre collection of weirdoes that live in his building keep life noisy, crazy, and just plain silly.  

Deciding to leave for the sake of his future and his sanity, Godai is heading for the door when the new apartment manager arrives.  Though all thoughts of leaving fly from his head after setting eyes on Kyoko, Godai will never be able to concentrate again.

MANGA VISION TEST

ARTWORK:  Rumiko Takahashi’s artwork, as always, is perfect for the story she wants to tell.  The action is always easy to follow and the characters are distinctive, if a little bit familiar from her other work.  The best thing about Takahashi’s characters is their range of facial expressions.  The characters are truly actors on the page, which adds to both the humor and the more dramatic moments.

SOUND EFFECTS:  The original sound effects have been removed and replaced with English translations.  This doesn’t really hurt the artwork, but some readers may wish the original effects had been left unchanged.

EDITS:  There seem to be no edits made to Maison Ikkoku.  I think that the original Viz version of this title was edited, but the edited material has been restored for the second edition.

EXTRAS:  The only extra is a brief “About the Author” page.

BOOK REPORT  

STORY:  Rumiko Takahashi is the most successful creator of comics and manga in the world for a reason.  Simply put, she tells great stories.  When you read a Takahashi manga, you will definitely laugh, you may cry, and you will always be entertained.  If you come to Takahashi’s work with high expectations, Maison Ikkoku will not let you down.  Many elements of this story have been “borrowed” by other creators over the years, but Takahashi’s work here still seems fresh and funny, despite this manga’s age.

TRANSLATION:  The translation seems well done.  The characters each have a unique voice, and the punch lines come through intact.

CHARACTERS:  Kyoko Otanashi is Maison Ikkoku’s new live-in apartment manager.  She is sweet and caring, and wants to do the best she can to take care of her tenants.

Yusaku Godai is a young university ronin, trying to pass his college entrance exams.  He is excitable and a bit immature, but he means well.  When he meets Kyoko, he falls in love at first sight.

Chubby Mrs. Ichinose and her bratty son Kentaro are two of Maison Ikkoku’s residents who absolutely revel in tormenting and embarrassing Godai whenever they can.

Akemi is a gorgeous young bar hostess who tends to stumble home drunk on a regular basis.  She also walks around the building dressed in skimpy nightgowns, loudly complaining when Godai looks.  She is very manipulative and has both the men and women of Maison Ikkoku firmly under her control.

Mr. Yotsuya is Godai’s goofy, yet well-dressed neighbor, who tends to dig peeping holes in the wall and blame them on Godai.

Mr. Soichiro is Kyoko’s loyal dog, named after the most important man in her life.

Tennis coach Shun Mitaka is the good-looking, super-suave ladies man that quickly proves to be a hazard for Godai’s chances with Kyoko.

FAN SERVICE:  There is always a bit of good, clean fan service fun in Ms. Takahashi’s work, and Maison Ikkoku is no exception.  Akemi regularly wanders around the building in some very revealing lingerie.  Godai has a few very vivid daydreams about his new manager, and Kyoko’s tennis outfit does allow an occasional flash of panties.  The fan service here doesn’t come across as particularly salacious though, and is really just sweetly naughty.

FOOTNOTES:

First things first:  when it comes to Rumiko Takahashi, I have a definite bias.  I am a huge Takahashi fan.  Her first major work, Urusei Yatsura, is my all-time favorite manga/anime series.  I have never read anything by Ms. Takahashi that I didn’t enjoy.  I will try to keep fanboy gushing to a minimum, but you have been warned.

Fans have long considered Maison Ikkoku to be one of the pinnacles of the romantic comedy genre.  Both the manga and the anime stand as classic examples of how this kind of story should be done. Maison Ikkoku was Takahashi’s first major new series after the smash hit of her debut with Urusei Yatsura.  Many of the elements of her first series reappear in this sophomore effort. There are conflicted young lovers, who just can’t seem to admit their feelings for one another.  There are wacky friends and neighbors, bratty kids, and tiny little wizened, sarcastic, old folks.  Despite these familiar elements, Maison Ikkoku is still a unique and distinctive tale.  The biggest difference between this series and most of Takahashi’s other work is the very grounded real-world feel to this story.  There are no aliens, no monsters, no dog-demons, and no gender-switching martial artists.  The story takes place in a world much like our own, just funnier.

The first volume of this series wastes no time introducing the major players in the story.  Within just a few pages, the characters feel like familiar old friends.  Each short chapter stands as a complete episode, while slowly adding to the overall plot and developing the characters. This is a refreshing change of pace from some modern series that take 200 pages just to get started!

Yusako Godai is a loveable loser, just trying to do something with his life.  No matter how hard he tries to earn a little respect, or just to get Kyoko’s attention, things never seem to go his way.  Godai is not the hopelessly idiotic wimp so often cast as the hero in this genre, he is just a regular guy whose best efforts always seem to go astray.  More often than not, the people around Godai are more to blame for his disastrous efforts to woo Kyoko than he is himself.  You will instantly find yourself rooting for Godai and Kyoko to get together, while laughing at the silliness around them.

Maison Ikkoku is the perfect example of a story that can be read and enjoyed by fans, casual readers, or even people new to the world of manga.  If you have never read anything by Rumiko Takahashi (and shame on you!) this is a great place to start.  If you are a fan of some of her higher profile work, like Ranma ½ or InuYasha, you owe it to yourself to try out this touching comedy classic.

Return to Top

Back to the Manga-Books Page

©All information protected by DVD Vision Japan copyright unless otherwise noted.